Ficam W and the 2012 New Zealand EPA Carbamate Reassessment

In November 2012 the New Zealand Environmental Protection Authority (EPA) released consultation documents for its reassessment of organophosphate and carbamate insecticides used in plant protection and biosecurity. Buried in that report was a line proposing to revoke the approval for Ficam W (bendiocarb 800 g/kg WP) on the basis that it was no longer used in New Zealand. Garrards, which supplied professional pest managers in New Zealand at the time, identified the error and had it corrected.

What happened

  • The EPA released its OPC Reassessment Consultation Report and a series of summary documents covering more than 35 crops and biosecurity on 2 November 2012, with comment open until January 2013.
  • Products used by professional pest managers were not meant to be part of the reassessment.
  • Section 10.19 of the report, Table 59, nevertheless listed bendiocarb 800 g/kg WP as no longer used in New Zealand and proposed a six-month phase-out and revocation of its HSNO approval.
  • PMANZ and Garrards had already made submissions in November 2011 listing the organophosphate and carbamate products used in professional pest management, including bendiocarb.
  • Garrards followed up and the EPA replied that it had overlooked that information, having understood the product to be for plant protection only, and apologised.

Why it mattered

Had the line on page 98 of a 194-page document gone unread, the HSNO approval for bendiocarb could have been revoked without consultation with the pest management industry, and pest managers would have lost access to Ficam W. Ficam W is a wettable powder, which leaves a residue that insects contact more readily than many other formulations, and it is not a synthetic pyrethroid, so it remains useful where some insects are less susceptible to that chemical group. It had been a stalwart of the industry for more than 30 years.

The lesson for Australian pest managers

The episode is a reminder that professional pest management can be caught up in regulatory actions that were never aimed at the industry. In Australia, APVMA chemical reviews and reconsiderations of older actives work in a similar way, and consultation documents are often long and framed around agricultural uses. Reading them, and lodging a submission through your industry association or your supplier when a professional use is at risk, is the only reliable way to make sure urban pest uses are not removed by default.

Available from Garrards

Garrards continues to supply Ficam W to licensed pest managers in Australia. Check the current APVMA label for registered uses and contact your branch for availability.

Contact your local Garrards branch