Does Lime Kill Fleas? The Facts for Pest Managers

Does lime kill fleas? For decades Australians have spread agricultural lime over soil, lawns and sub-floors in the belief that it smothers flea eggs and dries out adult fleas. Pest managers are regularly called to treat flea infestations where lime has already been applied, which says a lot about how well it works. This article looks at what “lime” actually is, what evidence exists for the practice, and why lime can make a professional flea treatment less effective.

The problem: a remedy with no evidence behind it

On the internet anyone can be an expert. Search for “lime for fleas” and you will find a multitude of recommendations, especially from pet-shop and natural-remedy websites, but no scientific references. Many simply repeat one another, which is how a myth acquires the appearance of authority.

When Garrards’ technical staff investigated, the most commonly cited source was a natural pet-health book that advises applying agricultural lime on grassy or moist areas to “dry out” fleas, after raking up dead leaves and grassy debris. Contact with the author did not shed any light on the matter: he did not know of any references or the origin of the remedy. Other sites advise mowing the lawn so sunlight dries out the fleas, or watering to drown the larvae. Yet fleas routinely multiply in dry sub-floors and hot, dusty conditions under the Australian sun.

There also appears to be an increasing incidence of flea treatments being required after lime has been applied. Perhaps on-animal treatments are failing, or perhaps lime is simply seen as a cheap, “natural” alternative.

Which lime? Four different things share one name

Part of the confusion is that several unrelated compounds are called “lime”:

  • Citrus lime extracts: d-limonene and linalool, extracted from citrus, are often recommended as natural on-animal flea treatments.
  • Agricultural lime (calcium carbonate): limestone crushed to a fine powder, used to raise soil pH.
  • Quicklime (calcium oxide): produced by burning limestone.
  • Hydrated or slaked lime (calcium hydroxide): made by adding water to quicklime; mainly used in the construction industry.

Old-timers will tell you “they don’t make the lime like they used to; it’s too coarse now and won’t work”, and that hydrated (slaked) lime was what people used in bygone days. Slaked lime is far more alkaline (pH about 12.4) than the mild calcium carbonate sold as agricultural lime today. If any lime ever killed fleas in the environment, it was probably this caustic product rather than the garden lime people now buy. That does not make it a good idea: the high pH is harmful to garden plants, and to any person or pet that comes into contact with it.

Curiously, a 1995 report of a dog dying after a natural insecticidal dip based on d-limonene described the citrus extract as “acting as a desiccant, stripping the insect’s cuticle of oils”. The claimed mode of action for citrus lime and agricultural lime is virtually identical, and neither is supported by published evidence for use on soil.

What lime actually does: it deactivates your insecticide

Agricultural lime spread on soil does have one well-documented effect, and it works against you. Lime is used to deactivate chemicals. Insecticides that are sensitive to high pH break down faster in alkaline conditions, so a treatment applied over limed soil is less likely to be effective and will lack residual activity. Hydrated lime degrades insecticides even more rapidly than agricultural lime.

Practical consequences for pest managers:

  • Ask the customer whether lime has been spread before you quote or treat. Where practical, removal of lime-contaminated soil is recommended before treatment.
  • Where removal is not practical, expect reduced residual performance and plan follow-ups accordingly.
  • Explain to the customer why the lime should not be re-applied after treatment.

Why treating the environment matters

Few people realise that fleas spend most of their life away from the host. In Australia the flea found on dogs and cats is almost always the cat flea, and its life cycle runs egg, three larval stages, pupa, adult. From the moment the egg drops off the host soon after it is laid, through the larval stages, until the adult emerges from the pupa as a potential host passes by, the flea has no contact with the animal at all. Larvae feed on flea droppings and organic debris in carpet, bedding, soil and sub-floor dust, and pupae can stay dormant for weeks until vibration, warmth or carbon dioxide signals a host is near.

That is why an effective treatment of the environment is as important as an effective treatment of the animal, and why an on-animal product alone so often disappoints. A professional flea program typically combines:

  1. Treatment of all pets with a veterinary flea product, on the vet’s advice.
  2. Thorough vacuuming of carpets, furniture and pet resting areas, and hot washing of pet bedding, to remove eggs, larvae and debris and to stimulate pupae to emerge.
  3. Application of an APVMA-registered insecticide to indoor and outdoor harbourage areas (carpets, sub-floors, shaded soil, under decks and along fence lines where pets rest) strictly according to the label.
  4. A follow-up inspection, because pupae that were protected at the time of treatment will continue to emerge for some weeks.

Safety and compliance

  • Flea treatments in Australia must use products registered by the APVMA and applied according to the label, by a technician licensed in the relevant state or territory.
  • Hydrated and quick lime are caustic. If a customer has spread them, advise them to keep children and pets off the area and to wear gloves and eye protection when removing it.
  • Do not apply insecticide over freshly limed soil expecting normal residual performance.

Frequently asked questions

Does agricultural lime kill fleas?

There is no scientific evidence that agricultural lime (calcium carbonate) controls fleas, and pest managers are frequently called to treat infestations where lime has already been applied. Its one reliable effect is to shorten the life of any insecticide applied over it.

Is hydrated lime better for fleas?

Hydrated (slaked) lime is highly alkaline and may have some effect on fleas, but it is hazardous to people, pets and plants and degrades insecticides even faster than agricultural lime. It is not recommended.

Why do fleas come back after I treat my dog?

Because most of the flea population is not on the dog. Eggs, larvae and pupae develop in carpets, bedding, soil and sub-floors, and pupae can emerge for weeks after treatment. The environment must be treated as well as the animal.

Downloads

Original article by Phil Sayer BScAgr, Technical and Training Manager, Garrards Pty Ltd.

Available from Garrards

Garrards supplies APVMA-registered flea treatments for professional use, application equipment and the PPE required to apply them, and can advise on product selection where lime or other soil amendments may affect residual performance.

Contact your local Garrards branch

Frequently asked questions

Does agricultural lime kill fleas?

There is no scientific evidence that agricultural lime (calcium carbonate) controls fleas, and pest managers are frequently called to treat infestations where lime has already been applied. Its one reliable effect is to shorten the life of any insecticide applied over it.

Is hydrated lime better for fleas?

Hydrated (slaked) lime is highly alkaline and may have some effect on fleas, but it is hazardous to people, pets and plants and degrades insecticides even faster than agricultural lime. It is not recommended.

Why do fleas come back after I treat my dog?

Because most of the flea population is not on the dog. Eggs, larvae and pupae develop in carpets, bedding, soil and sub-floors, and pupae can emerge for weeks after treatment. The environment must be treated as well as the animal.